Will piracy rip the spine out of ebooks?

19th Jan 2010 | 14:22

Will piracy rip the spine out of ebooks?

Ebooks will be big - but will pirates follow in their wake?

Ebooks and piracy

For years, the publishing industry has been waiting for its iPod moment, the time when electronic books become mainstream.

It looks like that moment will happen in 2010: this year's CES had more electronic books than a library for Daleks, and some outfit called Apple is apparently getting ready to release a tablet computer-cum-ebook reader that'll sell a few units. That's the good news.

The bad news is that if ebooks take off, the pirates won't be far behind.

Piracy is inevitable, but that doesn't mean piracy needs to do to the book industry what it did to music. To an extent the music industry was the architect of its own misfortune, responding to the threat of piracy with excessive DRM, too-high prices and format wars that confused and alienated customers.

So has the publishing industry learnt from the music industry's mistakes? George Walkley is head of digital for Hachette UK, the publishing giant whose imprints produce everything from the Twilight novels to textbooks.

"I think the publishing industry is keenly aware of the experience of other content industries," he told us, pointing out that while legal ebooks do indeed use DRM, "there has been considerable development work by technology vendors and publishers to balance a desire for copy protection with offering the consumer greater interoperability and flexibility."

Format fights

One of the things that sent people to the pirates with music was the problem of file formats: your player wanted X format, the pirate sites had it in X format, but the only legal versions were in Y format.

Publishers are keen to avoid the same thing in books. As Walkley points out, Hachette's US parent company was the first big publisher to adopt the epub format, a kind of MP3 for books, and Hachette UK uses epub, too.

George walkley

BEATING THE PIRATES: Hachette UK's George Walkley says the publishing industry is keen to avoid the file format woes that plagued early digital music services

Where epub doesn't work, such as when it comes to publishing the complex illustrations you'll find in educational books, Hachette UK uses PDF. "These are the only download formats for ebooks which we create as a matter of course - although some retailers may convert those master files or apply proprietary DRM," Walkley says.

"Most of the other major publishers have adopted similar strategies… the effect of this is that device manufacturers are increasingly supporting epub natively. For example, Sony recently took the decision to deprecate its proprietary BBEB ebook format in favour of epub, and nearly all of the new ebook readers announced at CES support epub."

Money, money, money

Digital downloads weren't cheaper than CDs, and for now at least ebooks probably won't be cheaper than print. That's partly because most of the costs apply whether you publish a book on paper or on an iPhone, and it's partly because of tax: "printed matter" books are zero rated for VAT, whereas electronic ones have to charge the full 17.5%.

It's a weird anomaly, and if we were in the book business we'd be lobbying Alistair Darling like crazy to get electronic books treated the same as printed ones.

The challenge for publishing is to avoid being seen as greedy. In music, the debate quickly became characterised as The Man versus The Kids, where The Man was Bono, his celebrity mates and their filthy rich record companies.

In reality, most musicians are struggling to pay the rent, but that's not what the average file sharer thinks.

Maybe novelist David Hewson has the answer. Writing on his blog, he says that he would "happily stick a button up here that said, maybe, 'Please Don't Steal My Book'. That could link to a simple website run by a group of authors' organisations, perhaps with quotes from well-known writers, which sets out the facts about what writers really earn, how much we actually get from book sales, and why using ripped-off copies will, in the end, damage the interest of both writers and readers."

It's got to be better than Bono's approach in the New York Times recently: when he drew parallels between file sharing and illegal porn and accused ISPs of stealing all his money, the entire internet torrented U2 albums out of sheer spite. Probably.

Should authors give their work away free?

The novelist Paulo Coelho links to torrents of his own books, while Boing Boing's Cory Doctorow has spent many years giving his books away for free, but that's by choice: the problem with pirates is that they share books whether the authors like it or not, and if they stick ads around the link they're making money from others' effort.

David Hewson for one is aghast. "I will happily write for nothing the moment supermarkets hand out free food, bars buckshee beer, petrol stations give away gas, and the taxman writes me a letter that starts, 'Annual return? Forget it. We don't need the money'. Until then I'd just like you to pay the modest price on the cover," he says.

Pirate books on file-sharing site

SMALL SCALE:Although ebook piracy certainly exists, it's not on the same scale as music piracy - or at least, it isn't yet

"There is a real danger that we're sliding towards a cultural shift which divides creative writers from their work, where copyright itself is somehow seen as theft, a conspiracy against a public that has a 'right' to take what it wants from the web for nothing," Hewson writes. "If that happens we're headed for fewer professionally published books, a poorer range of literature, and the dumbing down of mainstream publishing to a handful of established genres and big-time authors."

One thing that might help is the difference in demographics. According to the Books & The Consumer survey of UK book buyers, the average book buyer is female and aged 35 or older, whereas the typical music pirate is male and aged 16-24.

No prizes for guessing which type of person is more likely to respond to Walkley's argument that, ultimately, you get what you pay for: "I also think it's important that as an industry we emphasise that supporting the production and distribution of high quality content has a price, and that books – whether in physical or digital form – represent on the whole a very reasonably priced form of entertainment or education. Copyright infringement isn't a victimless issue: it affects publishers, but most importantly it affects the creators behind the books."

Poorly designed ebook

IMPERFECT:The quality of many dodgy ebooks would make a book designer weep. It's all poorly scanned covers and messily formatted OCR-ed text

We get the distinct impression that Walkley and his peers aren't keen on suing grannies and dead people.

"Copyright infringement cannot be prevented altogether, only reduced," he says. Speaking personally, he says he'd like to see action against the most egregious offenders - but he also says that the key is to give consumers what they want.

"One of the most important things we can do is to make the purchase of legitimate ebooks as easy and as convenient as possible and produce a broad range of titles in digital formats," Walkley says. It's a lesson that took the music industry more than a decade to learn.


Liked this? Then check out A history of the MP3

Sign up for TechRadar's free Weird Week in Tech newsletter
Get the oddest tech stories of the week, plus the most popular news and reviews delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up at http://www.techradar.com/register

Follow TechRadar on Twitter

ebooks piracy
Share this Article

Most Popular

Edition: UK
TopView classic version