Why Microsoft needs to nail a mobile gaming device

4th Mar 2013 | 16:38

Why Microsoft needs to nail a mobile gaming device

Microsoft needs to get into handhelds

PlayStation admitted back in late 2011 that Xbox was winning the current generation wars by a fair margin - fuelled largely by its popular Xbox Live platform and the addition of the Kinect accessory that impressed most far more than Sony's Move controllers.

Try as it might, Sony has had mixed success with the PSP but perhaps not in the way they'd intended. Outside of Japan it has appealed largely to the home-brew market that have used it as a portable console emulator (and a fantastic one it is too).

Rumours have flown around for a couple of years now regarding a portable Xbox that could contend with the PSP and Nintendo's offerings, though Microsoft hasn't commented directly on it themselves.

It may seem a little crazy to suggest it in the world of quad-core smartphones but having seen the direction that manufacturers such as Nvidia and Razer are heading with gaming platforms (Project Shield, for example), it's clear there is still a definite market for mobile gaming handhelds - if they can get the right balance of product and price.

Project Shield

Too prudent?

Ever since the mixed fortunes of the Zune hardware they've chosen the arguably more prudent route of tying Xbox Live in to the Windows platform. Unfortunately, the selection of games available for mobile doesn't quite echo the excellent selection that's available on the full-fat console.

iOS has had quality games since the start, and Android has had little problem more recently attracting the top developers but Microsoft's platform still lags behind, which considering its strong Xbox heritage seems crazy.

Microsoft would have you believe that the Surface and Xbox SmartGlass is part of their current answer to these problems of making Windows powered devices their contender to any dedicated handheld gaming hardware and to an extent they may yet be proved right.

The combination of this and Xbox Live could be the right route to take as smartphone and tablet sales dominate every other category out there . Type 'Microsoft Xbox handheld' in to Google and an advert for the Windows powered Surface tablet is your first result - making fairly clear their current position.

Many out there would still be very excited by a proper gaming handheld from Microsoft.

Others are trying

Though touch-screens have their place in casual gaming, the excitement that surrounded Project Shield at CES 2013 shows that many would still prefer physical interaction rather than the less precise jabs afforded by even the best screen. Microsoft is hopefully taking a lot of interest in projects such as this as well as the Razer Edge.

It may not be quite as portable as Nvidia's clam-shell design but echoing the Edge is a far more realistic route that Microsoft could go down with minimal effort to win over users to the Surface platform whilst making the Xbox brand truly mobile and not confusing things with yet another piece of new hardware.

Razer Edge

The biggest problem with taking this route is the cost of it all; a stumbling block which may well be too big a hurdle for Razer's tablet.

The Surface Pro is just hitting the shops. Which, when you consider the addition of any gaming accessories, is just too much for most gamers looking for a handheld - these customers would be more likely to fork out for a high-spec laptop.

As for the Surface RT, it's certainly got a nippy processor that has shown its worth for gaming on the Nexus 7, but can Microsoft really get the same performance out of it with Windows RT needing so much more of that processor's time than Android? We're still not sure - and neither are the consumers judging by most sales projections.

Any incentive?

So this brings us back full circle to the thought of why there's no dedicated handheld; what's stopping them?

Well firstly, there's more incentive for Microsoft to not take the risky route that the PS Vita has, even though it seems they have many of the elements required to.

Despite its high-spec hardware the Vita just can't compete with the convenience and price of smartphone gaming. Mobile apps have set the expectation of high quality games for an exceptionally low price.


Games that only a few years ago would have been considered worthy of a full retail release can now be had for a couple of pounds or less. These games appeal to so many who only have limited times to play games on the move but there's enough of a selection to satisfy even the most hard-core gamers, as long as they can tolerate the touch-screen interaction.

Sony tries to win over these gamers with titles that have only marginally less production values than their console equivalents but it seems that the mass market are no longer interested in shelling out £30 or more for a single game when it may turn out they do not even like the game.

What Microsoft needs to do

A mobile gaming device could run on the Windows Phone platform and therefore be reasonably affordable.

It would also have excellent integration with Xbox Live as well as being a companion to whatever the next gen Xbox turns out to be - likely unveiled at this year's E3.


Microsoft would need to get on-board its catalogue of Xbox developers with quality franchises and convince them that the mobile app model really is the way forward.

Taking SmartGlass to the next logical step of becoming a service that could stream games from the new console to a handheld platform would also surely prove a winning feature and something that is extremely appealing about Nvidia's Project Shield - though that system requires Steam to do the same tricks.

It needs to provide a comparable experience to that which people really love on the Xbox 360 and make it available to them on the move.

Could there also be an alternative? With the right combination of exclusive top titles and an accessible online experience, all that would be required to keep the controller-loving elite happy is for Microsoft to coax its hardware division in to come up with a convincing and compact accessory to turn Windows phones or tablets in to a portable console.

To get an idea what we're thinking of, take a look at products like the IcontrolPad 2 or PhoneJoy Play. Both are Kickstarter campaigns that aim to at provide the necessity for physical input. Both projects have been backed well above their prospective goals.

Microsoft Xbox SmartGlass
Share this Article

Most Popular

Edition: UK
TopView classic version